Makhakhe found guilty of corruption

151

Staff Reporter

MASERU — An internal probe has found Kubutu Makhakhe, the principal secretary for administration in the prime minister’s office, guilty of seven of the 10 corruption-related charges he was facing.

But Makhakhe will not lose his job because the disciplinary panel recommended that instead of being fired he should be reassigned to another position in the government. 

It said because Makhakhe was guilty of the majority of the charges he “should be reassigned to another post in the public service that will remove him from responsibility over procurement processes and also from being the chief accounting officer with overall supervising responsibilities”.

Makhakhe however says he will appeal the decision because he wants to have a clean record. 

He was suspended in February after a forensic audit into the prime minister’s office revealed he had approved transactions that benefited two companies with links to his wife, Mathungthung Makhakhe (Mrs Makhakhe).

The investigation also led to the suspension of four other senior department officials who are however yet to face a disciplinary hearing. 

Thato Masiloane, Makhakhe’s deputy, ’Marapelang Raphuthing, the finance director and two other procurement officers, ’Manthabeleng Shai and Lerato Moerane, are also being charged for alleged corruption related to awarding of tenders in the department.

Makhakhe’s charges emanated from two separate transactions that the department had with Ntsepeng Suppliers and Botle Business Furniture, companies which the investigators said were owned by his wife.

Makhakhe approved a M29 870 payment for Ntsepeng Suppliers and a M14 000 payment for Botle Business Furniture.

The department had bought stationery from the two companies.

On all counts Makhakhe was alleged to have breached provisions of the Code of Good Practices 2005 which regulate the conduct of civil servants.

The disciplinary panel appointed by government secretary Tlohang Sekhamane was chaired by Monehela Posholi, the chief executive of the Lesotho Communications Authority.

Sekhamane, who suspended Makhakhe and his four colleagues, was the complainant.

The verdict was delivered on Wednesday afternoon after three sessions.

Makhakhe was facing 10 charges in all — six related to Ntsepeng Suppliers and four to Botle Business Furniture.

On Ntsepeng Suppliers, Mkhakhe was accused of failing to declare his financial interest in the transaction as well as failing to withdraw from the department’s “evaluating team and process” that approved the tenders for the two companies.

He was also charged with failing to lead by example, bringing the civil service into disrepute and failure to “diligently and impartially” perform his duties.

The sixth charge was that he had failed to serve the people of Lesotho “with respect and promote their welfare and lawful interests”.

On the Botle transaction Makhakhe was also charged with failing to declare his interest and lead by example.

He was also accused of failing to serve the “welfare and lawful interests” of Basotho.

The fourth charge was that he had failed to perform his duties with “diligence and impartiality”.

The panel found Makhakhe guilty of all but three of those 10 counts. 

Posholi relied on evidence that showed that the postal address and phone number on the invoices that Makhakhe approved belonged to his wife.

During the hearing Makhakhe admitted that the contact details on the invoices belonged to his wife.

He however argued that the handwriting on the invoices did not belong to his wife and claimed the details might have been used by someone else without his or his wife’s knowledge.

But Posholi said the mere fact that Makhakhe had failed to notice that his wife’s details were on the invoices means he had failed to be diligent, impartial, lead by example and serve the lawful interests of Basotho with respect.

“Any signs of irregularity that may lead to conflict of interest or perceived favouritisim, such as the wife’s cellular phone number and postal address of oneself on supporting documentation (invoices), should be questioned to guard against compromising on the required impartiality,” Posholi ruled.

He said by approving the transactions with such glaring anomalies Makhakhe did “not demonstrate best endeavours on his part and certainly not a good example to others, including but not limited to, his subordinates in the ministry (prime minister’s office)”. 

Makhakhe’s decision to sign the documents with his wife’s details had brought his integrity into question and cast “some shadow on the image of the public service”.

Because of his oversight, Posholi ruled, Makhakhe had brought the public service into disrepute.

By being negligent in his attention to detail Makhakhe had failed to respect and serve the interest of Basotho and was therefore guilty of that charge, he said.

On the charges that he failed to declare his interest and withdraw from the tender process that benefitted the two companies Posholi found Makhakhe not guilty.

He said although the invoices contained Mrs Makhakhe’s contact details that alone was not enough to conclusively link her to the companies.

Posholi reasoned that the only way Sekhamane could have proven the link beyond reasonable doubt was to bring documents from the Registry of Companies showing Mrs Makhakhe as the director of the two companies.

A record of the companies’ board minutes or bank details showing Mrs Makhakhe’s name could have sufficed as evidence to prove the link.

In an effort to prove the link Sekhamane had produced a copy of Makhakhe’s marriage certificate during the hearing.

But Posholi said even this was not enough to conclusively prove that the companies were linked to Makhakhe’s wife. 

Makhakhe told the Sunday Express on Thursday he was going to challenge the ruling.

“I have to challenge the verdict because if I leave it like that it will damage my reputation,” Makhakhe said.

He also complained that he had not been given the forensic audit report that led to his charges.

Share.

About Author

151 Comments

  1. The residential camps are held on eight college campuses in the
    U. Pay attention to deadlines so that you
    do not get your application in too late. Each day children will be able to select one of the activities that they most
    want to engage in. Put pan over camp fire with some oil or butter
    in it. There are a wide variety of fit camps to choose from, however, so consider the following points before joining in it.
    The men would take some time to wash up which usually meant washing their hands and face in a bowl
    of water and drying with a community towel unless a man happened to have his own locked in the trunk.
    The parents who attend love it, including graduating with their children on the final day.
    Many also offer console games for the PS3, XBOX 360,
    and Nintendo Wii. ) Discuss with students what thoughts the paintings bring to mind, or what emotions they might
    evoke. They provide 4 and 5 star accommodations, wherein single rooms will be given to each couple with a majestic personal bathroom and quality services.

    Look into my page overnight camps for boys delray beach

  2. A Los Gatos plumbing expert is a strategy to all of your plumbing Los Gatos problems.

    ” In little time at all, the completed washing was spinning away drying in the only dryer, I was standing under a well eared hot shower giving myself a good rubdown. Do not just ask any plumber to come over and do some immediate repairs.

    my web blog … install tub
    pompano beach fl

  3. Professional responsibility principles should
    be incorporated into every area of office operations and procedures.

    He or she should be a person who would be in a position to utilize resources for the benefit of the organization. Various accounting firms allow students to serve as interns.

    My website :: Fort Lauderdale CPA firm

  4. In December 2012, she was half way through her reconstructive procedure and has since become a symbol of hope for women suppressed by the Taliban, urging women to “never give up and don’t lose hope,” that “what happened, it’s part of me, part of my life and its all the time in my mind and with me. And a proficient plastic surgeon with a lot of experience, can take that even further. The American Board of Plastic Surgery, retrieved from website on February 18, 2012.

    my blog post facial plastic surgeon Jobs

  5. Aside from that, interview former patients to obtain first-hand
    insight into a particular cosmetic surgeon’s methods,
    approach, and techniques to plastic surgery. An experienced plastic surgeon can ensure you
    appealing aesthetic results with the help of innovative body contouring procedures.
    With an type of plastic surgery, there will be a recovery process.

    Look at my webpage … stop bloody nose

  6. These are really greast ideas in concerning blogging.
    You hhave toujched some pleasant things here. Any way keep up wrinting.

    Allso visit my webpage :: games

  7. I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it up!

    I’ll goo ahhead and bookmark your site to come bacfk down the road.
    Many thanks

  8. Profollica Best Treatment for Men improves hair body and suppleness and protect against harmful sun damage
    and itchy and scalp conditions. If the drugs damage cell activity
    during the anagen phase, then hair loss is noticeable within a couple of weeks.
    Autoimmune problems such as baldness and psoriasis are known to be
    exacerbated by stress; daytime fatigue and emotional distress are the
    most commonly reported symptoms of sleep deprivation.

    Here is my web-site :: laser hair Treatment for hair loss at home gaunitz

  9. Choose a soap that will cleanse your body and not just perfume it a
    little bit. The US National Library of Medicine warns
    against ingesting this petroleum product. If our body is producing
    skin cells to repair wrinkles, there would be no problem at all,
    and all wrinkles would be temporary in nature.

    Here is my webpage clarisonic mia 2 on sale

  10. Replacing the wax ring is a lot less difficult and expensive than replacing the toilet, but if
    you have wanted a new commode, this is your chance. ” In little time at all, the completed washing was spinning away drying in the only dryer, I was standing under a well eared hot shower giving myself a good rubdown. Toilet paper is among the most essential product because you are always going to need it and you use it all the time.

    Feel free to visit my web page :: leaking water heater city of pompano beach

  11. It is usually at this point that the most junior member of
    the household suggests that maybe I should put more water in the
    bowl so that the plunger has half a chance of success.
    Flat paint is the best choice for hiding rough spots and surface imperfections, which makes it perfect for ceilings and walls.
    When you pull the toilet handle, the flapper rises and
    allows the water in the tank to empty into the toilet.

    Check out my page: fix dascor plumbing pompano beach

  12. Fiat money:Fiat money refers to money that is not backed by
    reserves of another commodity. Finally upon withdrawal from the account, there is
    no tax to be borne, leading to an all round attractive investment proposal for those with
    the disposable income to afford it. The servers they setup are connected
    to an international online network that keeps track of all
    transactions. Any form of money which has been assigned a greater value than the raw materials it is
    made from alone is at risk from counterfeiting reducing its value.

  13. The questions you should ask your plastic surgeon before rhinoplasty
    should be about the safety of the procedure, its efficiency, and most importantly,
    its appropriateness for your body and whether it would offer results in line
    with your expectations. Nathan Newman is world renowned for his advanced cosmetic surgery procedures.

    If nothing else, it is more “beach and tan” culture than the West LA So many people seeking cosmetic
    surgery and there are many thousands of them who can afford it.

    My blog post – facial plastic surgeons grand rapids mi

  14. Hi! Quick question that’s totally offf topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly?
    My website lools weird wheen browsing from my iphone.
    I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to correct this issue.

    If you have any recommendations, please share.
    Cheers!

    my weblog games

  15. *If the IRS receives no response, you may receive notice for additional tax assessment or audit.
    You are entitled to Medicare, even if you are not enrolled and are
    not receiving benefits. For costs of home-based DUI, robbery and assault immigration-linked or another tricky New York Tax
    Attorney, New York Bankruptcy Attorney, New York Traffic Ticket Lawyer
    firm trouble, he promises to zealously promoter
    for your own interest.

    My page: Boca Raton CPA machines

  16. You can keep your spray tan longer by using products that will not only preserve its color but also enhances
    it. So try to follow the tips aforementioned to get rid of the farmer’s tan. Does it give out an aura of all-around cleanliness.

    Here is my webpage: professional Fake tan

  17. If you have any questions pertaining to where and ways to utilize web site (
    super fast reply ), you can contact us at the web
    page. Is he an active member of a Plastic Surgery Association or Society.
    This will give an assurance that the treatment which has offered
    is effective and suitable for you.

    Feel free to surf to my web page; plastic surgery milwaukee

  18. Tanning allows you to experiment with different styles and
    looks. New to the market is a Bikini Thief St Barts tankini in a two piece.
    Moving to some sunny place can be an effective means to get an all round glow.

    my web-site … tan

  19. You need to decide what your objective is before getting involved with
    social media marketing, which will result in greater success than if you were to go
    into it without any idea of why you’re really getting involved.
    Long haul targets are the final consequence of all these deliberations – more prominent deceivability,
    profit and gainfulness. In the world of Internet, there is no magic formula
    that will guarantee success every time when you introduce New Ideas.

    Here is my webpage; witches’ market

  20. Are you taking the CPA examination and fear that you’re not gonna pass it.
    If you are misplaced and don’t recognize how to start on your search for an IRS Penalty Abatement, make use of
    a skilled expert to obtain IRS Assistance. Learning
    how to get your gambling winnings tax back can be quite beneficial to you, especially if
    you find a refund management company that can assist you in getting this rebate without a lot of hassle and fuss.

    My web-site … george ponczek cpa boca raton

  21. You stood up for the rights of all people of a great
    nation in combat, but unfortunately, you must
    continue to stand up for yourselves to ensure that
    the promises of being taken care of upon your
    return are kept. Accounting software will automate your transactions,
    which helps eliminate a chance for error caused due to manual data-entry mistakes.
    Every aspect of your business needs to be recorded in order for it to
    be analyzed for accuracy.

    Feel free to surf to my homepage :: charles brandon fort lauderdale cpa

  22. Ahoj Nevadilo by vám, sdílení, který blog platformu jsi pracovat s?

    Já bude za?ít sv?j vlastní blog brzy ale já jsem s t?žké
    mezi BlogEngine / WordPress/B2evolution a Drupal.
    D?vod, pro? se ptám je, protože vaše layout Zdá se
    liší pak v?tšina blog? a já jsem hledal n?co, jedine?ný.

    PS Omlouvám pro jak off-topic, ale musel jsem se
    zeptat!

  23. I take pleasure in, result in I discovered exactly what I used to be taking a look for.
    You have ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a
    great day. Bye

    my web site Crazy Taxi City Rush Hack (Caleb)

  24. Lawyer or attorney Victorianne Musonza, Lawyer At Laws, Licensed in NY And NC, Maxwell Law Office, PLLC is accepted to rehearse rules in Rhode –
    Tropical isle and Massachusetts, so the Federal government Section Courts,
    which is a member of the Pub of the us Superior Court.
    Educating these customers in how to handle their tax affairs
    in the future can save them many thousands
    of dollars. I decided to use their OIC service to lower my tax bill.

  25. What’s Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this
    I’ve found It absklutely helpful andd it has aided me out
    loads. I am hoping to contribute & assis other customers like its aided me.

    Grat job.

  26. C?T iss the only format in ?hich the test is offered bbut if requested at the time of ap?lication, ??rtain accommodations in accordance with the Americans with Disabi?ities Act (A?A) can be ma?e for
    specific candidates. After re?ching my accountant and relaying m? concerns, the nexdt attribute worth addressing is communication. The skills you
    acquire in your training to become a CPA will give you confidence in yo?rself and your newfound abilities.

  27. ?rank Breinling i? a recognized expert in Affuliate Marketing.
    For ?xample, it ccan g?ve yoou ad?ice on the maintenance
    of inventories of ?orporate merrgers and acquis?tions, and exxpansion of the business.
    A CPA must complete a certain amount of CPE (Continuing Professional Education) unitts ?ach year.

  28. M?nagement F?aud often involves a senior manag?ment. After rea?hing
    mmy accountant and rel?ying my ?oncerns, the next attribute worth addressing is communication.
    T?ere are somje things people fail to think ov?? andd oone of th?se iis dealing with mone?.

  29. I think what you posted was very logical. But, think on this, what if you wrote a catchier title?
    I mean, I don’t wish to tell you how to run your website,
    but what if you added a post title that makes people desire more?
    I mean Makhakhe found guilty of corruption | Sunday Express is a little plain. You might peek
    at Yahoo’s home page and see how they create news titles to get viewers to click.
    You might add a video or a related picture or two to get people excited about what you’ve
    got to say. Just my opinion, it would make your posts a little livelier.

  30. Thanks for the marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you can be a great author.I
    will be sure to bookmark your blog and will come back
    very soon. I want to encourage yourself to continue your great writing, have a nice evening!

  31. Today, I went to the beach front with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave
    it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.”
    She put the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is completely off
    topic but I had to tell someone!

  32. We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme
    in our community. Your website provided us with valuable information to work on. You’ve done a formidable
    job and our whole community will be grateful to you.

  33. I’m not that much of a online reader to be honest but your blogs really nice, keep it up! I’ll go ahead and bookmark your site to come back later. Many thanks

  34. Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So good to search out any individual with some authentic thoughts on this subject. realy thanks for beginning this up. this web site is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality. helpful job for bringing one thing new to the web!

  35. Your website provided us with valuable information to work on. You’ve done a formidable
    job and our whole community will be grateful to you.