Makhakhe found guilty of corruption

151

Staff Reporter

MASERU — An internal probe has found Kubutu Makhakhe, the principal secretary for administration in the prime minister’s office, guilty of seven of the 10 corruption-related charges he was facing.

But Makhakhe will not lose his job because the disciplinary panel recommended that instead of being fired he should be reassigned to another position in the government. 

It said because Makhakhe was guilty of the majority of the charges he “should be reassigned to another post in the public service that will remove him from responsibility over procurement processes and also from being the chief accounting officer with overall supervising responsibilities”.

Makhakhe however says he will appeal the decision because he wants to have a clean record. 

He was suspended in February after a forensic audit into the prime minister’s office revealed he had approved transactions that benefited two companies with links to his wife, Mathungthung Makhakhe (Mrs Makhakhe).

The investigation also led to the suspension of four other senior department officials who are however yet to face a disciplinary hearing. 

Thato Masiloane, Makhakhe’s deputy, ’Marapelang Raphuthing, the finance director and two other procurement officers, ’Manthabeleng Shai and Lerato Moerane, are also being charged for alleged corruption related to awarding of tenders in the department.

Makhakhe’s charges emanated from two separate transactions that the department had with Ntsepeng Suppliers and Botle Business Furniture, companies which the investigators said were owned by his wife.

Makhakhe approved a M29 870 payment for Ntsepeng Suppliers and a M14 000 payment for Botle Business Furniture.

The department had bought stationery from the two companies.

On all counts Makhakhe was alleged to have breached provisions of the Code of Good Practices 2005 which regulate the conduct of civil servants.

The disciplinary panel appointed by government secretary Tlohang Sekhamane was chaired by Monehela Posholi, the chief executive of the Lesotho Communications Authority.

Sekhamane, who suspended Makhakhe and his four colleagues, was the complainant.

The verdict was delivered on Wednesday afternoon after three sessions.

Makhakhe was facing 10 charges in all — six related to Ntsepeng Suppliers and four to Botle Business Furniture.

On Ntsepeng Suppliers, Mkhakhe was accused of failing to declare his financial interest in the transaction as well as failing to withdraw from the department’s “evaluating team and process” that approved the tenders for the two companies.

He was also charged with failing to lead by example, bringing the civil service into disrepute and failure to “diligently and impartially” perform his duties.

The sixth charge was that he had failed to serve the people of Lesotho “with respect and promote their welfare and lawful interests”.

On the Botle transaction Makhakhe was also charged with failing to declare his interest and lead by example.

He was also accused of failing to serve the “welfare and lawful interests” of Basotho.

The fourth charge was that he had failed to perform his duties with “diligence and impartiality”.

The panel found Makhakhe guilty of all but three of those 10 counts. 

Posholi relied on evidence that showed that the postal address and phone number on the invoices that Makhakhe approved belonged to his wife.

During the hearing Makhakhe admitted that the contact details on the invoices belonged to his wife.

He however argued that the handwriting on the invoices did not belong to his wife and claimed the details might have been used by someone else without his or his wife’s knowledge.

But Posholi said the mere fact that Makhakhe had failed to notice that his wife’s details were on the invoices means he had failed to be diligent, impartial, lead by example and serve the lawful interests of Basotho with respect.

“Any signs of irregularity that may lead to conflict of interest or perceived favouritisim, such as the wife’s cellular phone number and postal address of oneself on supporting documentation (invoices), should be questioned to guard against compromising on the required impartiality,” Posholi ruled.

He said by approving the transactions with such glaring anomalies Makhakhe did “not demonstrate best endeavours on his part and certainly not a good example to others, including but not limited to, his subordinates in the ministry (prime minister’s office)”. 

Makhakhe’s decision to sign the documents with his wife’s details had brought his integrity into question and cast “some shadow on the image of the public service”.

Because of his oversight, Posholi ruled, Makhakhe had brought the public service into disrepute.

By being negligent in his attention to detail Makhakhe had failed to respect and serve the interest of Basotho and was therefore guilty of that charge, he said.

On the charges that he failed to declare his interest and withdraw from the tender process that benefitted the two companies Posholi found Makhakhe not guilty.

He said although the invoices contained Mrs Makhakhe’s contact details that alone was not enough to conclusively link her to the companies.

Posholi reasoned that the only way Sekhamane could have proven the link beyond reasonable doubt was to bring documents from the Registry of Companies showing Mrs Makhakhe as the director of the two companies.

A record of the companies’ board minutes or bank details showing Mrs Makhakhe’s name could have sufficed as evidence to prove the link.

In an effort to prove the link Sekhamane had produced a copy of Makhakhe’s marriage certificate during the hearing.

But Posholi said even this was not enough to conclusively prove that the companies were linked to Makhakhe’s wife. 

Makhakhe told the Sunday Express on Thursday he was going to challenge the ruling.

“I have to challenge the verdict because if I leave it like that it will damage my reputation,” Makhakhe said.

He also complained that he had not been given the forensic audit report that led to his charges.

Share.

About Author

151 Comments

  1. What’s Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It absolutely useful and it has helped
    me out loads. I hope to contribute & assist other customers like its helped me.

    Good job.

  2. Paleo Eating is the purest form of food. It comes direct from mother nature.
    There is no artificial in between. Paleo Foods contains unprocessed fruits, vegetables meats seeds e.t.c .
    It leaves out dairy stuffs and grains. And, all the modern day fast foods and oily foods are
    out if Paleo diet. Paleo diet is what ancestors used to eat some 5000 years back.
    There was no agriculture then, so they ate direct from nature.
    This made them healthy. Did you know our ancestors used to live much more than 100 years.
    They didn’t got chronic illness like heart ailments and other stuffs.
    Therefore you need to understand that Paleo Eating is the top way to stay disease free.
    It will protectfrom common and severe chronic problems.
    You will never suffer from heart issues or diabetes likes sickness.

    You would be strong and healthy with very low fat in . You will have lots of of energy.

    paleo recipe book

  3. Search for them on i – Tunes or your favourite app store.
    With this you can organize all your information
    in a single place. Here we Identify the considerations you
    may wish to take if you decide to outsource some of
    the i – Phone app creating project.

  4. Find bargains for the family at local garage sales.
    On the website or through the smartphone apps, you can view
    your energy usage and compare your usage to people in your geographic region or across
    the globe. It’s african american and roughly how large a new football;
    the actual converter operates if the machine is for the cool placing, and also the thermostat is set for a frigid temperatures.

  5. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I to find It really useful & it helped me out
    much. I’m hoping to offer one thing again and help others like you aided me.

  6. Hey, I think your sire might be having browser compatibility issues.
    When I look at your website in Chrome, it looks fine buut when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then
    that, awesome blog!

    Review my blog … 223 ammunition for sale

  7. Right here is the right blog for everyone who really wants to
    understand this topic. You understand a whole lott its almost tough to argue with you (not that I
    actually will need to…HaHa). You definitely put a brand
    new spin on a topic whic has been discjssed
    for a long time. Excellenbt stuff, just great!

    Also visit mmy web-site – where to buy ammo

  8. hello there and thank you for ylur info – I have certainly
    picked up something new from right here. I did however experdtise a few technical points
    using this website, as I experienced to reload the site lots of times
    previous too I could get it to load correctly.

    I hhad been wondering if your web host is OK? Noot that I aam complaining, but sluggish loading
    instances times will sometimes affect your placement in google and ccan
    damage yourr quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords.
    Anyway I am adding this RSS to my email and could look
    out for a lot more of your respective intriguing content.
    Make sure you update this again very soon.

    Here is my web site … financial planner new york life

  9. The leading plastic surgery clinic in Sydney specializes in offering all types of cosmetic surgery including Face lift,
    otoplasty, Rhinoplasty, Scar – Revisionn, Fat injection and Eyelid surgery.
    They use high-end techniques, innovative surgical methods and state-of-art machines
    to deliver excellent result. They also exhibit a
    willingness to answer questions and to make a patient feel safe and comfortable.

    My web-site; plastic surgery on nose

  10. Orissa is in the process of working with group homes of dysfunctional children. With the
    growing trend of online shopping, more and more websites are
    emerging with quality hair care products for sleek and shiny hair.
    We don’t want to end up old and wrinkled because we spent every other
    day in a tanning booth.

    my blog – Clarisonic Skin Care

  11. If you want a much more colorful variation on the vintage military
    aviation watch theme, check out a French watchmaker called Bernard Richards Manufacture (B.
    The stainless steel case is square and you can choose rose-tone or black.

    One of the easiest ways of accomplishing such a seemingly lofty
    feat is actually rather simple at heart.

  12. Hello there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be ok.
    I’m absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new posts.

  13. Remember that the diet is meant to control your glucose
    level and if it fail to do it, there are other options
    for this task. One of the disadvantages of low-calorie diets is that it makes you feel constantly hungry.
    “She’s been on a diet ever since, because they have to be up to par, so she looks terrific.

    Also visit my web blog – hcg Drops diet Reviews

  14. whoah this weblog is magnificent i like studying your articles.
    Stay up the good work! You know, a lot of people are
    searching round for this info, you could help them greatly.

  15. My goal as a doctor is to provide the best possible vision to everybody.

    If the eye doctor you are going to see does not have all their credentials or
    their certifications or license is expired,
    you should find a new doctor to perform the cataract surgery on you.

    Leaving out letters or adding letters on to words, having trouble writing in a straight line, and misreading small
    words like.

    Feel free to visit my weblog … glasses with prescription brooklyn

  16. As a result of the need in controlling and regulating industry through
    both direct and indirect methods, two steps must be carried
    out. Prepare an application for Tax-ID number, if needed.
    Understand that when you enter a major tax franchise or
    chain your taxes are most likely being prepared by
    a trained.

    Also visit my homepage … Boca Raton CPA jobs

  17. I do not even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post
    was great. I do not know who you are but definitely you’re going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!

  18. We helped several nonprofits from grassroots to international with their marketing and
    fundraising efforts. We’ve seen some organizations fitting the social media plan and begin off on a sensible note however it quickly turns to dry wood when not
    followed through. You can learn a lot from these consultants for the management of your
    business and the way of solving the operational problems.
    It’s an investment that is well worth the effort, and can have a significant and positive impact on your company’s image
    as well as the bottom line. Where can they find the time to interact with their fans on these social networking sites.
    Social media networking working sites have put an ending to fan sites because social media sites assist the fans to get access to their
    favorite fans and they will even be able to interact with
    one another. To get the best results from social media, create links
    that tie them all together. Obtaining normal traffic is very effortless with the help of pay per click advertising
    campaigns, but nevertheless the situation regarding that is this: they do
    not convert very well and also it costs money. By exclusively using
    your stream for follow up and customer interaction purposes, you can satisfy your customer base,
    maintain a constant social appearance, and preserve your privacy at the same time.
    Linked – In and Facebook are probably the two best sites for entrepreneurs to begin with.

    Feel free to surf to my page :: internet marketing company

  19. There is a nice deal of commitment needed to arrange and maintain social media strategy.

    This is the world’s most popular social networking site, with over 200 million users.
    Now that you have a ballpark figure for how much your
    networking campaign has cost you for just one month of starting and
    maintaining the campaign for five networks, how much have you
    made from those networks. People get tired of reading that kind
    of content really quickly. A Google Authorship shows local authority or authority within a niche or industry.

    Social networking sites like myspace and facebook have great importance in business
    promotion. Take advantage of the holidays by keeping your customers informed.
    It is important to realize that your response to comments
    can be seen by everyone. And remember that there may be some things you don’t know.

    For example, we want peace in the household so we end up giving in to
    our wife over and over to please her.

    My web page – marketing agency boca raton fl

  20. On the other hand, a quality of long standing durability and
    features like color & clarity of acrylic beads
    is much better than the glass beads. Laughter, smiles and playfulness were the norm
    for his photos, but it was not in fashion photography.
    Perhaps you are a model who wants to expand your portfolio with a range
    of startling shots that show off your versatility and individual flair.

    Here is my blog … bodycon dresses krushgirlz big cartel

  21. If you need 20 points in Medicine or you can just lie.
    Clearly, the prospect of a typical morning jog or
    walk is not the most exciting idea for most people. Vancouver Hockey Camps offers
    lessons and training that teaches kids and youth competitive hockey skills designed to improve overall individual and team playing ability.
    The destructive attitude and misbehavior in the kids at growing age
    can easily be controlled. Summer can be focused on sports, music, games, horseback
    riding, archery, golf, swimming, boating, nature life,
    crafts, dance, or any variety of activities. For most of us, our
    home qualifies as our single biggest expense and investment.
    I don’t care what camp you train at, you are going to get in shape faster in Thailand on a “training holiday” than you
    would in your own town. In all likelihood, there will be plenty of other people who are
    just getting back into fitness themselves. Also, be cautious of camping stores that sell camping supplies since prices are usually much higher than normal.
    Many individuals out there are trying to find methods to make additional money.

    Here is my web-site … boys summer camp delray beach

  22. This minimizes the associated risk involved and helps marketers
    to better understand the demands of the evolving customers.
    It really doesn’t make a difference if you’re an international hotel
    chain or a small brand, social media can certainly
    benefit you immensely. Watch for requests to come in, and
    accept as appropriate. The tips in this article will help you use social media
    to your advantage. Maybe you want to increase brand awareness to bring in new leads.

    You should deliver content that’s interesting with links back to your
    website. Recently I was doing my whole deal,
    spinning someone on their head for a seriously
    flawed perspective of the world, and the person freaked out and started accusing me of all manner of things
    which were either 1. These sites can suck you in and before you know it, all your studio time is gone.
    You could for instance let your subscribers know about your sales volume, the launching of new products or the anniversary of your most popular
    products. Now, sit down and write a letter to this target customer or client.

    Here is my page boca raton social media marketing how to

  23. Tanning salons have high tech machines that will evenly spray
    the solution onto your entire body. This not only saves your body from harm,
    but it saves you time and money as well. This is
    because in order for the spray tan to be effective, the person will need to avoid showering for twelve hours after their spray tan. You want a natural-looking golden sheen to
    your skin. This will make the skin more hydrated
    allowing the spray tan solution to stick well over it. Therefore,
    make sure that their spray tanning equipment is clean and well maintained.
    In this facet, obsolete electronic components can make
    up the shortcomings. As the dangers of outdoor and indoor tanning are becoming increasingly
    apparent, many consider the safe and effective alternative of spray tanning to achieve a natural
    glow. I was in the bathroom with one foot on the closed toilet lid slathering up a leg and
    watching in fascination as ominous clouds darkened the sky and a storm
    blew in. If you are looking for a product like the “Tan Overnight Self Tanning Lotion 27 Set,” you can find this on their website along
    with the “Tan Overnight Self Tanning Lotion 8 Set.

    Here is my web site – fake tan band

  24. This involves regular physical check-ups, a good diet and exercise and regular dental check-ups.

    Garcinia Cambogia Extract diet is a simple weight reduction method that needs
    no change in lifestyle. Specifically how does hydroxycitric acid in Garcinia cambogia Work.
    Oz also has discussed green coffee bean extract as another weight
    loss “miracle. This is the weight loss remedy that you’ve been waiting for. When we add rich fiber food in our diet, waste material passes through the body quickly and do not stay in the intestines or bowel for long time, toxins are not able to accumulate. The fruit through which the nutritional supplements are formulated is actually indigenous to South East Asia, and is typically identified as pumpkin like in outline, although merely the size of a good sized orange. It helps me to take my mind off the workout when I start getting a little tired of it. You may want to lower your weight, without the harmful chemicals. This compound is highly reputed for its numerous health benefits, including the control of blood sugar levels and the stimulation of metabolism.

    my site … hydroxycitric acid walmart

  25. In simple words, fashion illustration gives a freedom to
    the artist to put forward the fashion designs and ideas in front of the entire world.

    The XXI century is certainly century fashion, where existing trends
    have a strong influence on society. Almost every day
    we are exposed to the damaging effects of the ultraviolet rays that are
    sometimes high in radiation.

    My blog post bandage dresses size 14

  26. Each person should develop their own definition of beauty.
    For me, the decision to join Javita was a no brainer. So what is the science behind the
    supplement’s being a fat blocker. So, whenever you take a capsule of
    Pure Garcinia Cambogia, you are actually waging
    war against the fat cells that are stubbornly clinging to your organs,
    making you sicker by the day. Instead of delegating certain chores to
    an office assistant, take it upon yourself to get up and physically take care of it.
    is a magic word for millions of people today who are suffering from low self-esteem owing to their excess
    body mass. Maintain a new Sleep Diary – There is no formulation intended for excellent slumber, because you will have to try out every thing and pay attention to just what operates in your
    case. The Garcinia Cambogia extract contains hydrocytric acid with clinical studies
    showing that it helps to control appetite and prevents fat production. Dermaloss weight loss patch also has other forms, including a patch that
    contains Hoodia Gordonii, the active ingredient found in plants native to Africa.
    The label encourages the customer to participate in the process by
    recycling the packaging whenever clear.

    Feel free to visit my webpage :: verified garcinia cambogia reviews

  27. There is a blue LED indicator light to show when the phone is synced or being
    charged, so if this light isn’t illuminated during
    use then something is definiotely wrong. The Dynamo Illuminator Wind-Up Flashlight is an essential
    green gadget for anyone who wants to avoid throwing away
    or recharging batteries. Foor several purposes we utilise multiple electronic gadgeets like
    cell phone, internet modem, etc.

    My web page recharge cell phone Without charger

  28. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much
    about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
    I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home
    a little bit, but instead of that, this is
    magnificent blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.

  29. Big principle is, you are interested in listening to, but doo not let everyone think you are broadcasting station. You will feel
    the comfortable and nice of the Europe town. You can readily browse the
    front pages of the magazines (both the latest and older issues).

  30. Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I
    guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say,
    I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still
    new to the whole thing. Do you have any helpful hints for inexperienced blog
    writers? I’d really appreciate it.

    Feel free to visit my web page :: 3 day diet lose 10 pounds in 3 days

  31. Regulatory restraint for lenders is also hastening the distortions.
    Most Section 8 tenants will avoid doing anything which will
    jeopardize. Top 10 Marketing Strategies for Real Estate Investors.
    I had endowed my dear 99 horse statues and the stuffed animals on my bed with the power to protect me.
    ”Groundwork is not like “longeing” – longeing
    refers to putting a horse on a long lead, or longe, and sending
    her around in circles at a trot or even a canter for as long
    as it takes to tire her out before mounting. The rent that you ask for
    will depend on this figure. You could literally create any design you can think of and
    give more personality to your home. Minh Phams
    next real estate investing seminar will be held in Alexandria, VA on March 14th, 2009.

    There are several platforms to invest your money today.
    This is because of the up to date infrastructures and amenities surrounding them just like clean environment, connected roads, better transport, great accessibility
    and lots more.

    My webpage commercial real estate foreclosures

  32. Employers seem to be taking a greater and greater interest in their employees’ Facebook posts.
    Is It Worth Paying Someone To Teach You Social Media. ” This type of post was formerly thought to be cute, but now readers are plugged into so many feeds that they
    will only read what benefits them. But there’s still time to catch up and transform your ‘anti-social’ business into a social networking
    success by implementing basic techniques to get your business in the
    groove. Remember, one blog per week on your website is the
    basic minimum you should aim for. It has become an important platform for
    popular culture, news reports, and even business. Platforms such as Facebook,
    Twitter and the recently launched Google+ for
    business have become a powerful tool for marketing professionals
    interested in creating conversations around brands, products or companies.
    We’ll teach you how to start using popular social networking sites, how to link
    these sites with your existing websites, and even show you
    some fantastic apps to keep your fans updated wherever you go.

    If you choose to search the internet for solid information that tells how to use social media then you spend time.
    There are thousands of methods and strategies that can work and make you money,
    but you will need to find the suitable one and act
    accordingly.

    my web blog – Delray Beach Social Media Services

  33. If you are considering getting into the trucking business,
    you may be thinking about getting your CDL and starting a career driving a semi-tractor hauling trailers.
    Check out their insurance details too as accidents can happen,
    nobody can prevent it if it is bound to happen. The movers can easily clean the
    things from your house in very less time.

    Stop by my site: storage Companies like pods

  34. Event page on Facebook, fan page announcement, the first auto responder
    on your list, announcement and blog all should happen at the same time.

    You will be the one managing all of these so that
    they can focus on running their business. Just want to quickly see a return, do not want to
    spend more time thinking about how reasonable inputs, so
    a lot of people in the planning affect consumers through social media strategies lost too much should be doing.
    That’s $100-$300; $250-$750; or $500-$1500 a week
    to maintain your following list. For more on using the Internet
    to raise donations, visit our website for Online fundraising tips.

    There is no doubt about it publishing is hard, there is a lot of
    comppetion out there and even having great contacts in the publishing world does not
    guarantee you success. Group shows are more of a possibility if
    people know you and your work, in addition to a little of your personality.
    Companies conduct market research to learn more
    about their customers, keep up with market trends and forecast future business conditions.

    Being consistent is the best thing you can do to get visitors to return to
    your page. t have to get a million dollar budget to
    reach your target market.

    my homepage – boca raton social media marketing services

  35. I loved as much as you will receive carried out right here.

    The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish.
    nonetheless, you command get bought an edginess over that you
    wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come further formerly again since
    exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this increase.

  36. My relatives every time say that I am wasting my time here at web, but
    I know I am getting experience daily by reading thes
    nice posts.

    For the best solution please jump over to this web-site – doctor